The answer to the question “What Sets Caragiulos Apart from Other Restaurants in Sarasota?” is something other business and restaurant owners, especially those whose menu includes Italian cuisine, would like to know. Perhaps the best answer is to take a dream from the clouds to the ground and do whatever it takes to make that dream a reality.

Although it isn’t cited specifically, perhaps the reason Tony Caragiulo and his family departed New York for Florida was climatic; however, we do know that while driving around Sarasota in 1989, they espied the perfect location and set out to introduce the best of their native Italian cuisine to the rest of America. Their New York experience in the bakery business is kept alive every day as Mama Anna Caragiulo prepares breads including biscotti and focaccia from scratch.

Caragiulos occupies a beautiful, majestic Spanish/Mediterranean architecture building situated 12 minutes from Sarasota’s airport and one block from its main downtown bus st

At Caragiulos, we serve a delicious dinner after you take the time to explore the Sarasota area. From walks along the sidewalks in front of the small stores to taking a walk to the beach, there is an abundance of things to do in the city. We are one of the city’s most popular restaurants that serves Italian food. Our restaurant is open seven days a week to serve those who desire a meal that is made with fresh ingredients. We offer a little bit of everything from pasta and fresh tomato sauce to various types of seafood prepared in numerous ways.

We are conveniently located a block from beautiful Bayfront Park and a short 12 minute ride down Route 41 from the Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport. Bus transportation is available and bus stops are 1 block away. We are directly off of Main Street in downtown sunny Sarasota, Florida. From Route 41, turn onto Main Street, then make a right on S. Palm Avenue and continue to the end of the block. We are located on the left-hand side. You’ll know you’ve arrived when you see our palm tree lined street and gorgeous Spanish-revival architecture. On-street parking is available as well as a nearby parking lot, follow the blue parking designation signs at the corner. We look forward to seeing you!

Fine Dining at Caragiulos Restaurant Serving Italian-American Cuisine

At Caragiulos Italian American Cuisine Restaurant, our goal is to provide the best dining experience in the Sarasota area. Our family immigrated to New York and enjoyed generations of home cooked meals before venturing to Florida and establishing Caragiulos family restaurant in 1989. We soon became a favorite among residents here and visitors alike. With favorites like biscotti baked fresh daily, our family traditions become your culinary delight.

Our traditional, but up to date decor is inviting and comfortable. The restaurant is divided into three dining areas, one in the bar area and the main dining room and our outdoor dining area. No matter where you sit, you will enjoy tantalizing taste sensations such as you’ve never known. We serve traditional Italian cuisine that is reminiscent of the Mediterranean Italian fare. We keep our Italian food authentic and serve American favorites alongside it for those with a l

Enjoy Fine Italian Dining in Sarasota

If you’re tired of visiting the same old fish houses every time you visit Sarasota, give this iconic Florida city a chance–it may be hard to get away from all the deep-fried po’ boys and other typical Floridian comforts, but you could always stop in at Caragiulos, an Italian joint that would love to meet you.

Refresh your palate with our calamari fritti, or a plate of our hand-cured Italian meats with a fresh homemade infusion. Fall in love with our Margherita Pizze, or get fancy with the Crispy Maple Farms Duck. When you take your friends and family to Caragiulos, you’ll find out why we won the 2015 Certificate of Excellence from Trip Advisor, and your folks will wonder why they ever questioned your great taste in Sarasota dining.

If you’re in the mood for some delicious Italian cuisine, Caragiulos features a full menu of delectable dishes. Since 1989, our restaurant has been serving the best Italian-American food to hungry customers in Sarasota, FL.

Savory Food Choices

When you come to our restaurant for lunch or dinner, you’ll have the opportunity to select from our wide range of mouthwatering meal options. Classic favorites include our spaghetti with house-made meatballs, eggplant parmigiana and Da Vinci pizza. After finishing your meal, stick around and try our spumoni, Nutella cheesecake or one of our other scrumptious desserts. We even offer biscotti that’s baked by Mrs. Caragiulo herself.

Welcoming Atmosphere

Our talented servers will do whatever it takes to make you feel right at home when you dine with us. We’ve designed a family-friendly restaurant setting that will make it seem as though you’re eating at the home of a good friend.

Caragiulos is the place to go for an excellent meal and

Our Italian restaurant has been in business for 27 years. During the summer months, we will offer various specials for 27 cents. The specials are for select drinks and food items. We are open seven days a week for those who are visiting the Sarasota area or those who live in the city and want a delicious meal that includes pasta and fresh ingredients. Bread is baked fresh each morning along with other items that are made in the restaurant instead of being ordered from suppliers. Our restaurant features a sitting area where guests can laugh and talk while waiting on their food or enjoy time together after the meal.

Caragiulos is found in Sarasota, Florida and if you are looking for a good meal, look no farther. This restaurant boasts authentic Italian-American cuisine. This restaurant opened in 1989 and has been making stomachs happy since then. The mozzarella is made fresh in-house, as well as the biscotti. And the aroma of fresh baked bread fills the air at Caragiulos.

Caragiulos is open for lunch and dinner Monday-Friday and for dinner on Saturday and Sundays. No matter what Italian dish you are craving, Caragiulos will not disappoint. Favorite dishes include the mussels, chicken parmigiana, veal piccata, and other favorites cooked to perfection.

The next time you are in Sarasota, Florida be sure to stop in for a great meal at Caragiulos.

While you’re exploring some of the new attractions in Sarasota, FL, stop by Caragiulos for a delicious meal. We offer a range of menu items from pasta to chicken. Many of the ingredients used in the dishes are fresh from local companies. Whether you’re visiting the New Tampa Nature Park or relaxing at Barefoot Massage, you can end your day with a glass of wine or one of the decadent desserts that we offer. There is plenty of indoor seating as well as a bar area if you only want a drink or to talk with friends in an intimate environment.

While walking along the streets of Sarasota, stop by Caragiulos to get a delicious Italian dinner. We prepare as many ingredients that are used in the recipes fresh that day. From spaghetti with meat sauce to a large plate of lasagna, you will find everything on the menu that you would find in a traditional Italian restaurant. Enjoy your meal outdoors while sitting in the warm evening sun of summer. Music is often played that has an Italian flair, offering a bit of relaxation when you’re inside the restaurant. There is a wine list available, and decadent desserts can complete your meal.