At Caragiulos, we’re proud to offer authentic American-Italian cuisine. Our menu includes classics like hand-tossed pizza with homemade tomato sauce, eggplant parmigiana, chicken Marsala, and a variety of pasta dishes. We also offer gluten-free and whole wheat pasta. We’re also extremely proud of our Italian style dessert menu which includes handmade cannoli and gelato that is made in-house. Our bread is also baked fresh in the restaurant each morning and we make our own mozzarella. We use only the best ingredients to ensure that all our homemade foods are fresh and tasty.

At Caragiulos, we’re one of the best dining places in the Sarasota area and we enjoy bringing a taste of Italy to all our guests. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite to each for lunch or a special dinner with a loved one, Caragiulos is an excellent choice for great food and a comfortable atmosphere. We’re family owned and operated and have been since the beginning. Mrs. Caragiulo even bakes the biscotti fresh every morning. We want our guests to have the experience of great food, a relaxed atmosphere, and the feeling of sitting down for a classic Italian meal whenever they come in for a visit.